Chaos as East Cambs council set to abandon its own draft local plan

In breaking news this morning, East Cambridgeshire district council has announced it is set to abandon its ill-fated draft local plan. The move follows the receipt by the council of the Planning Inspector’s list of the main modifications she wants to the plan before it can be accepted as ‘sound’.

The council is saying that it intends to withdraw the draft plan and rely instead on the previous (2015) plan.  That is the one, residents will remember, that was adopted in April 2015 and then torn to shreds within three months by a successful appeal by speculative developers Gladman, against the council’s refusal of 128 houses at Field End in Witchford.

The changes required by the Inspector (apparently – the council has not published the Inspector’s modifications at the time of writing, despite having issued a lengthy press statement about them) include:

  • increasing the housing numbers on allocated sites and the removal of the protection of green spaces in Witchford (the most significant increases in housing numbers are in Soham, Littleport and Sutton)
  • deleting the policy that requires development to respect the needs and characteristics of a particular named settlement
  • deleting the policy for community-led development [the council’s ‘Community Land Trusts’]
  • deleting the policy for higher disability access standards.

The Full Council meets on Thursday 21 February at 6:00PM, and councillors will be asked to agree that the Local Plan be withdrawn and that the Council revert to using the 2015 adopted local plan. I’m sure many issues will be raised at that meeting, but just a few of them are:

  1. How will local communities across East Cambridgeshire be protected from speculative development using only the 2015 local plan, which was shown to be as much use as a chocolate teapot within three months of its being adopted?
  2. What effect will this have on the validity of the (adopted) Fordham Neighbourhood Plan, on the Sutton Neighbourhood Plan which is inching towards its referendum, and on other Neighbourhood Plans currently in various stages of development such as Witchford’s?
  3. How will the council ‘be able to demonstrate a five year land supply in April 2020’ as the council says in its press statement – and what does this mean in practice?
  4. And not least, how much has this farrago cost the council tax-payer to date, and how much will it cost to put it right?

More news, I am sure, in the days, weeks, months, and probably years to come.

UPDATE 1 (13/2/19 at 13:12): Inspector’s letter and modifications (finally) online at https://www.eastcambs.gov.uk/local-development-framework/examination-documents

UPDATE 2 (13/2/19 at 13:43): it now appears that the Inspector sent her local plan modifications to the council on 19 December and wrote to the council on 25 January to complain that they had not been published. The council has sat on this news for almost two months.

East Cambs councillors refuse to endorse council trading company report

Well, that was interesting.  Today’s meeting of East Cambridgeshire district council’s Shareholder Committee (the committee which represents the council’s interests in its own ‘East Cambs Trading Company’) was asked to recommend the company’s business plan to the full council – and refused to do so.  Company directors were sent back to do some more homework, and a rewritten business plan will come to the next meeting of the Shareholder Committee.

So what went wrong?  Well, councillors have been more than a little irked that Palace Green Homes – the company’s house-building arm, responsible for such projects as the Barton Road houses in Ely – decided it wanted to move offices to Fordham, and plans for this were quite advanced before even senior Conservative councillors knew.

But questioning from me and from Conservative councillors today centred on the financial figures given to councillors, particularly for the company’s grounds maintenance operation. The salary bill for this team is expected to increase by almost £100K in the next two years, while its earnings before tax are projected to fall from £131K to less than £50K over the same period.  Transport costs are also set to increase, from under £60K to nearly £90K.

I’ve got other concerns too.  There are clear conflicts of interest between the council, the company, and the Combined Authority which is lending the company a lot of money – and there are some people on all three.  The company is aiming for only 25 per cent of the homes it markets over the next five years to be affordable – that’s less than the requirement the council asks of commercial developers.  (That’s partly because so few affordable houses will be generated by the scheme to refurbish the MOD homes at Princess of Wales in Ely).  And the company has been given the power to take unlimited loans from Mayor Palmer’s Combined Authority, rubber-stamped by only one named officer and one named councillor.

Finally, the Barton Road scheme included a payment by the company to the council, for an affordable home to be built somewhere else in the district. The money has been paid over, but there is no news about where, or when, the affordable home will be built.

Recent planning applications

The following planning applications in the Sutton division have been published by East Cambridgeshire District Council.

18/01770/FUL
Little Downham
14 Second Drove Little Downham CB6 2UD
Change of use for existing agricultural storage shed to B2 (retrospective).

19/00105/FUL
Mepal
Site west of Broadmead Witcham Road Mepal
Wooden single garage with attached carport.

19/00117/OUT
Witcham
Land south of 10A The Slade Witcham
To erect a two storey dwelling.

Further information can be found on the district council’s planning pages. If you would like to respond formally to the council about any planning application, comments should be addressed to the district council and not to me.  Comments may be made

  • online using the council’s public access webpage (the link above);
  • by email to plservices@eastcambs.gov.uk;
  • or by post to the Planning Department, The Grange, Nutholt Lane, Ely, CB7 4EE.

Recent planning applications

The following planning applications in the Sutton division have been published by East Cambridgeshire District Council.

19/00109/FUL
Mepal
Site west of Springleys Paddock Witcham Road Mepal
Two detached two storey dwellings.

18/01817/OUM
Sutton
Land Opposite 142 The Row Sutton
Outline planning permission for the erection of 20 dwellings (including 30 per cent affordable) with all matters reserved apart from access.

19/00097/FUL
Witcham
10 The Orchards Witcham CB6 2LR
Single storey rear extension.

Further information can be found on the district council’s planning pages. If you would like to respond formally to the council about any planning application, comments should be addressed to the district council and not to me.  Comments may be made

  • online using the council’s public access webpage (the link above);
  • by email to plservices@eastcambs.gov.uk;
  • or by post to the Planning Department, The Grange, Nutholt Lane, Ely, CB7 4EE.

Liberal Democrats conference in Histon

Liberal Democrats in Cambridgeshire and Peterborough enjoyed a well-attended conference in Histon today.  I was particularly pleased to chair a session with Dame Carol Black (Principal of Newnham College Cambridge) and Dr David Cleevely, tech entrepreneur and start-up business funder, who joined us to discuss their work as part of the Cambridgeshire & Peterborough Independent Economic Commission.

The purpose of the Commission was to examine how the Mayor’s Combined Authority could meet its commitment to the Government to double the size of the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough economy in the next 25 years, and its final report was published in September last year.  Carol and David discussed a wide range of issues including the enormous health inequalities between the north and south of Cambridgeshire and their relationship to work, and different ways in which growing the three different economies (Greater Cambridge, Greater Peterborough, and the fens) might be addressed.

Chris Powers of Cambridge Stays and Cambridge parliamentary spokesman Rod Cantrill updated the conference on the latest twists and turns of Brexit.  Mark Robertson, Principal of Cambridge Regional College, provoked a lively discussion about post-16 education, and South Cambridgeshire councillor Neil Gough described the emerging plans for the ‘Oxford-Cambridge corridor’ including rail and road connections and large numbers of new homes.

Speed limit change in Pymoor

As the local county councillor for Pymoor, I have been asked to consider objections received in relation to the proposed 30MPH speed limit on various roads in Pymoor.  I have written today to the county council as follows, to support the proposed change to the speed limit:

‘I have considered the proposal to reduce to 30MPH the current 40MPH speed limit in Main Street, Straight Furlong, Pymoor Lane and School Lane in Pymoor.

I am aware that the proposed speed limit was advertised as required by legislation, and have considered carefully the two resulting letters of objection.

I have read and understood the contents of the officer’s report entitled Objections to 30mph Speed Limit in Pymoor. After having taken note of the objections therein and considered the officer’s recommendation I support the implementation of the proposal as published.’

Recent planning applications

The following planning applications in the Sutton division have been published by East Cambridgeshire District Council.

19/00022/FUL
Little Downham
7A Tower Road Little Downham CB6 2TD
Rear extension plus canopy and porch (resubmission of 18/00355/FUL).

19/00045/OUT
Mepal
Land adjacent to 16 Bridge Road Mepal
Two proposed dwellings (phased development).

19/00048/OUT
Mepal
Land north of 12B Bridge Road Mepal
Two proposed dwellings (phased development).

Further information can be found on the district council’s planning pages. If you would like to respond formally to the council about any planning application, comments should be addressed to the district council and not to me.  Comments may be made

  • online using the council’s public access webpage (the link above);
  • by email to plservices@eastcambs.gov.uk;
  • or by post to the Planning Department, The Grange, Nutholt Lane, Ely, CB7 4EE.

Draft Private Sector Housing Enforcement Policy

East Cambridgeshire District Council has opened its consultation on its draft Private Sector Housing Enforcement Policy 2019.

The council tries to work with landlords to improve housing standards without enforcement, but also needs to ensure that where appropriate, enforcement action is taken where landlords are reluctant to maintain properties to a satisfactory standard.

The policy has been revised to include new and amended legislation. It sets out the council’s approach to enforcement which the council says is designed to be fair to responsible landlords and to also deal effectively with non-compliant or rogue landlords.

View the draft Private Sector Housing Enforcement Policy 2019

If you would like to make comments on the policy, please complete the two-minute survey below

https://www.surveymonkey.co.uk/r/VJ8BVB8

The consultation will last for eight weeks, closing at noon on Tuesday 19 March 2019.  Any responses received after the consultation deadline cannot unfortunately be considered.

Recent planning applications

The following planning applications in the Sutton division have been published by East Cambridgeshire District Council.

18/01815/OUT
Sutton
Site south of 9-13 The Row Sutton
Outline planning permission for 6 dwellings with all matters reserved apart from access.

18/01796/OUT
Witchford
41 Ward Way Witchford CB6 2JR
Single storey 3/4 bedroom dwelling, parking and associated works.

18/01821/FUM
Witchford
Land between 225 and 239 Main Street Witchford
The construction of 45 dwellings including external works, roads and parking.

Further information can be found on the district council’s planning pages. If you would like to respond formally to the council about any planning application, comments should be addressed to the district council and not to me.  Comments may be made

  • online using the council’s public access webpage (the link above);
  • by email to plservices@eastcambs.gov.uk;
  • or by post to the Planning Department, The Grange, Nutholt Lane, Ely, CB7 4EE.

Recent planning applications

The following planning applications in the Sutton division have been published by East Cambridgeshire District Council.

18/01827/HEN
Witcham
The Bungalow Hive Road Witcham
Single storey rear extension which extends beyond the rear wall by 5.3m, has a maximum height of 3.78m and an eaves height of 2.25m.

Further information can be found on the district council’s planning pages. If you would like to respond formally to the council about any planning application, comments should be addressed to the district council and not to me.  Comments may be made

  • online using the council’s public access webpage (the link above);
  • by email to plservices@eastcambs.gov.uk;
  • or by post to the Planning Department, The Grange, Nutholt Lane, Ely, CB7 4EE.